Seth Godin to Stop Publishing Books

I’ve been saying for the last 2 years that for speakers, coaches, consultants and others who write non-fiction that the “book deal” is a dead dog. With some of the most creative minds in the world publishing online (much of it free) you have to start seeing that if you are going to print a physical book – it’s primary function is as a premium marketing piece.

Here’ is what Seth Godin – veteran of 12 NY Times Bestselling books, has to say:

“I’ve decided not to publish any more books in the traditional way. 12 for 12 and I’m done. I like the people, but I can’t abide the long wait, the filters, the big push at launch, the nudging to get people to go to a store they don’t usually visit to buy something they don’t usually buy, to get them to pay for an idea in a form that’s hard to spread … I really don’t think the process is worth the effort that it now takes to make it work. I can reach 10 or 50 times as many people electronically.

No, it’s not ‘better’, but it’s different. So while I’m not sure what format my writing will take, I’m not planning on it being the 1907 version of hardcover publishing any longer.”

BAM! Look inside what he says here for the truth about the publishing paradigm:

The Long Wait – it is not uncommon for a book to take more than a year to come to market. How much is obsolete by the time a book written a year ago makes it to the store. Reminds me of the evil practice of AT&T making you sign a 2 year contract on a cell phone that will be obsolete in a few months.

Filters – There are a lot of voices and politically correct people in the “business prevention department” who will try to get you to homogenize the flavor out of your book. This is the crap that caused Dave Chapelle – one of the most creative comics of our time – to walk out on a multi-million dollar contract and the #1 show on Comedy Central – and just go to South Africa to calm down.

“As we celebrate mediocrity all the boys upstairs want to see
How much you’ll pay for what you used to get for free”
Tom Petty – The Last DJ

Well, Tom Petty pretty much hits it on the head as he satirizes the record industry – who stubbornly clings to “albums” and spending millions on DRM (digital rights management) while a 12 year old with free software can rip that song and upload it to a peer to peer filesharing website in Belize where there is no copyright laws.

I have loaned out my umpteenth copy of The Four Hour Work Week and I can tell you for sure – the physical book is a very hard medium to get an idea to spread by.

What could Godin mean? What other forms are there?

Chris Anderson, editor of “Wired” magazine and author of the groundbreaking “The Long Tail” published his recent book “FREE” for – well – free – on Scribd.com for a month, yep, just gave the whole thing away for free.

Even before he removed the free version it sold a bunch of books. Now the introduction and the first chapter is online free.

“Perhaps the printed book will become a premium product, ordered online, or in smaller boutique stores (think niche). For speakers, coaches, and consultants it has long been a good idea to consider your print book a premium marketing – or lead generation piece – or even a loss leader – to generate qualified leads and to demonstrate credibility.”

In my course The Speaker Machine – we cover what I call The Buzzy Book in Week 3. The Buzzy Book is a functional creation that is strategically developed to get you booked as a speaker – and secondarily as a profit item. Selling books when you speak has always been a nice extra money source for speakers – but more and more I’m thinking we should be using whatever means we can to capture email optins from our live presentations.

But, hey, don’t you think that if Seth put on a few pounds – he’d look nearly as handsome as me?


Subscribe or Live in Perpetual Darkness!


  • http://jeanettefisher.com Jeanette

    Yes Rick, Seth would almost look as good as you if he put on a few pounds.

    Doesn’t it seem odd that you can publish a book in a few weeks and the big publishers, with teams of employees, take a year?

    Teach Seth how to smile.

  • http://blog.simonhay.com.au/ Simon Hay

    I think e-books will get books to market quicker, but the quality might suffer. It’s up to writers to be professional. I think there’s a lot of material online that’s not worth reading, but I agree, non fiction is taking a beating. I’m online to build a platform, but I’ve still got good stories for books. The long waits a killer. Nice post, and thought provoking. Thank you, Simon.

  • http://www.tueffert.com Curt Tueffert

    Rick, great post. I was at an NSA-Houston chapter meeting Saturday and we began to question ALL the stuff we typically do for back of room sales, spin off business, etc. Great question, what is the next revolution in book publishing? Kindle? iPad? Seth is a visionary…

  • http://www.princeedwardislandstrokerecovery.blogspot.com Gary Gray

    Hi Rick, nice post. Our writers group now has something like 12 to 15 hard copy books that we have self published over the past five year period. Our target market is local an sales have met our expectations.

    Seth is right! Books are FAST becoming an e-item especially with reading tools like the iPad.

    The MOVE is ON! But hey, the technology just makes it easier and faster than ever before to share our creative work globally.

    The book is dead, long live the book!!!

  • Rick

    Hey Jeanette – yes we are much more speed to market than the almost glacial big publishers. They have so many little things to consider – like other books even they will be putting out in your topic or category – and forever the budgets to promote.

    In the end publishers get your book in a book store, it is up to authors to get books out of bookstores by promoting.

  • Rick

    Curt – you are so right. I was listening to the NSA presentation I did back in Portland 5 years ago (just published to this site for free) and we were already talking about the merit of getting the email address of the audience as being more important than selling a product.

    I think I still have a scar across 3 knuckles from balancing that box of books on top of my rollerboard suitcase handle!

    It sucks to haul product to the meeting – sucks to send it home – and really sucks to do all that and not sell anything.

    I’m most struck by Seth’s discussion about putting out an idea in a form that is very hard to spread.

    Wonder what he’ll do?

  • http://www.fridaytrafficreport.com/ Jack

    The King has spoken. Actually, the real king of paper book publishing, Stephen King, isn’t he also doing electronic/web publishing?

    All the smart ones who can call their own shots and take their fans with them have to go this route – if they haven’t already.

  • http://www.ryanhealy.com Ryan Healy

    I’m a sucker for physical books, but I’m old school like that. Perhaps there’s a way to have the best of both worlds — print and digital — without have to deal with slow-moving publishing houses?

    The whole idea of the print book as a premium product makes sense to me. After all, die-hard book collectors usually want high-quality books anyway (not cheap paperbacks).

    Ryan

  • Steve Markowski

    According to Seth, the physical book is a souvenir of the idea that gets out and about pretty much for free.

    So how about a book-size box with bookcover graphics to sit on your shelf. Inside some of the blood, sweat and tears that went into the writing – maybe a copy of some hand written notes – and, oh yeah, a lock of your hair.

  • http://www.nikableu.com Kimberly

    Hey Rick!

    Good piece; my friend Marian Hartsough just listed her book “Publishing for Publicity – How to Promote Your Business With a Book” on Amazon.

    As a book publisher she encountered just what you reveal about “traditional methods” of publishing and that is why she stopped doing it. Her book speaks to this very point, and I am sending her a link to your post. (Great minds…)

    As for the almighty email optins: maybe someone should write a book telling certain gurus how NOT to treat their list, lol. Too many people who disregard manners, ethics, and common sense.

    You have NEVER done that and it is why I open your emails.

    Best Regards from Carmel -

  • http://neillneill.com Neill Neill

    Cause for thought. I have only one book, and after a lot of research, I self published it…both printed and ebook.

    I wonder if there is a public perception that if a book isn’t printed, it’s not a “real book.” But if it is printed, and therefore real, then I’ll buy the digital, less-expensive version.

    Just a thought.

  • Pingback: Paperback Writer Beatles Music Video for Buzzy Book | Rick Butts

  • http://www.grandparentsbeingparents.com Debbie Nichols

    This just confirms my beliefs that self publishing is the only way to go. I was told always print your book, people view you as an author and e-books won’t represent you as the expert.

    But my question now is, what about kindle? You have to provide a electronic platform.

  • http://NearlyLiveTV.com Jim Zaccaria

    I think you pretty much ‘nailed’ it Rick. Lots of e-options.
    I believe we’ll be seeing pre-ordering of print books for ‘old-schoolers’ who like the ‘feel’ of a book. [besides, writing in the margins has screwed up my laptop screen] I also think there’s a market for premium priced custom autographed versions.

    I got this interesting PDF release from @ProsperityGal just the other day http://ifiwouldhaveknownjustonething.com/#cover

  • Rick

    Thanks to everyone who has commented here – I really appreciate ya’ll and you’ve written some very interesting stuff.

    I am bustin’ my tail to get ready for a live teleseminar tonight for Speaker Machine and haven’t had time to do you justice for taking the time.

    I’ll get back in here and follow up with you very shortly. Thanks again.

  • http://www.recommendedbookstoread.com/ Jose Lira

    I think that inevitably ebooks will be the way of the future, which will not totally kill printed books, but will definitely be an option to democratize the publishing industry, given that printing and distribution costs are reduced to virtually zero when you publish your own ebook, there are thousands of people that would not be able to do it the traditiona (paper) way.

    Good Post.

  • Pingback: 11 Social Media and Technology Books You HAVE To Read

  • Pingback: 11 Technology and Social Media Books You HAVE To Read

  • Pingback: Loy Okezie ≡ 11 Must Read Technology and Social Media Books

  • Pingback: Paperback Writer Beatles Music Video for Buzzy Book | Stardust Factor